wagyl wrote:Because confronting someone with a camera when they are not comfortable about it will always result in a win for you, no matter how good or bad the other person's actions are...
From my own experiences in this area, I get the feeling that one of the strongest motives here is jealousy, jealousy that the person leaving has such freedom of action that they can afford to take a few risks, which means that they have room to manoeuvre so that they don't have to take the first measly offer made. When I make an exit, I do my darnedest to make sure it is from a position of strength, so that I can be firm about the terms I am after. To my surprise, that hasn't resulted in any burned bridges either -- perhaps it has resulted in greater respect. There have been times that I got the strong impression that the middle manager I was leaving wished that he could do the same, but financial commitments prevented him from making any move.
I forgot the Japanese term for this but when people leave a company a lot of the "please don't go" or "we need at least three months' notice to do handover" is for the sake of the person leaving not the company. It's a way of making them feel like they were really valued and life couldn't possibly go on without them. It's like when someone insists on getting the whole bill at the bar you have to insist on covering your share three times before letting them pay. More junior employees haven't learned this yet and really take it to heart and feel like they're backstabbing their managers or something. The higher up the totem pole they are the less seriously they take it.