Hot Topics | |
---|---|
What’s mine is yours: build bridges by sharing cultures
Edward Said, author of “Orientalism,” comes up in every discussion of cultural imperialism or “appropriation.” As his nearly religious adherents are keen to tell us, any “Western” comment on or borrowing from “Eastern” culture is at best totally inappropriate, at worst an attempt to exert cultural control.
This time a Cambridge college, Trinity Hall, has been forced by these adherents to change the theme of its summer party from a “Tokyo to Kyoto” celebration of Japanese culture to the foolproof, if bland, “Metropolis.”
A typical criticism came from a half-Japanese student who, in a scathing article about the event, said the theme used their Japanese identity as a “prop and costume.” The student rallied to Said, saying the event promoted a “dehumanizing and offensive” presentation of Japanese culture that “feeds into the history of objectification and fetishization of Asian people.” The organizers of the event, dismayed at the negative reception of their theme, changed it in order to “not be divisive.”
[...]
But Japan? Really? Isn’t the blanket application of Said’s “Orientalism” to everything, to all issues relating to cross-cultural experiences, foolish? Worse, doesn’t it get in the way of creating bridges between ourselves and others?
When it comes to Japan, their formula just doesn’t work. Japan, the world’s third biggest economy, home to the corporate behemoths of Sony and Toyota, was never a victim of imperialism, but was itself once an imperial power.
But more importantly, what those who are attempting to “defend” a country from Western appropriation forget is that Japanese people are very happy to see their culture being shared around the world.
[...]
The Cambridge students organizing the “Tokyo to Kyoto” event had partnered up with the university’s Anglo Japanese Society (AJS), clearly illustrating their goal of cultural appreciation rather than appropriation. Sae Kawakami, head of the AJS, expressed her sadness over the theme cancelation, saying: “As a native Japanese student, I feel strongly about sharing Japanese culture with the Cambridge community. The June event was an opportunity to celebrate Japanese culture.”
Another Japanese student, Isabella Yamamoto, commented: “For the most part, my English friends have a genuine interest in Japan, but have rather limited knowledge, leading to slightly ignorant questions like ‘Do you eat sushi every day?’ When I heard about the theme, I was excited because I would finally be able to share elements of Japan that I love with my university friends, such as the Bon-Odori dance, which is a fantastic part of Japanese culture.”
Okazaki spoke enthusiastically about the potential for events celebrating Japanese culture, saying they make people more “aware of your culture” and therefore more accepting of it. The Trinity Hall event was a chance for Cambridge students, most of whom cannot afford an expensive plane ticket to Japan, to learn about some aspects of Japanese culture, and to develop greater cultural empathy.
yanpa wrote:Personally I am sick and tired of my British culture being appropriated by so-called British-themed pubs in Japan, which are inevitable poorly-thoughtout cliches of the original, pandering to local prejudices about Britishness and sweeping aside careful consideration of ethnic and cultural historical identies. Have members of the British community been consulted about this trivialisation of their culture for entertainment purposes? I demand protests and long articles featuring complicated academic words such as "implicit dichotomisation".
wagyl wrote:yanpa wrote:Personally I am sick and tired of my British culture being appropriated by so-called British-themed pubs in Japan, which are inevitable poorly-thoughtout cliches of the original, pandering to local prejudices about Britishness and sweeping aside careful consideration of ethnic and cultural historical identies. Have members of the British community been consulted about this trivialisation of their culture for entertainment purposes? I demand protests and long articles featuring complicated academic words such as "implicit dichotomisation".
Check your privilege, white boy!!!
yanpa wrote:Personally I am sick and tired of my British culture being appropriated by so-called British-themed pubs in Japan, which are inevitable poorly-thoughtout cliches of the original, pandering to local prejudices about Britishness and sweeping aside careful consideration of ethnic and cultural historical identies. Have members of the British community been consulted about this trivialisation of their culture for entertainment purposes? I demand protests and long articles featuring complicated academic words such as "implicit dichotomisation".
yanpa wrote:wagyl wrote:yanpa wrote:Personally I am sick and tired of my British culture being appropriated by so-called British-themed pubs in Japan, which are inevitable poorly-thoughtout cliches of the original, pandering to local prejudices about Britishness and sweeping aside careful consideration of ethnic and cultural historical identies. Have members of the British community been consulted about this trivialisation of their culture for entertainment purposes? I demand protests and long articles featuring complicated academic words such as "implicit dichotomisation".
Check your privilege, white boy!!!
Are you stereotyping my ethnicity and gender identity?
Russell wrote:yanpa wrote:Personally I am sick and tired of my British culture being appropriated by so-called British-themed pubs in Japan, which are inevitable poorly-thoughtout cliches of the original, pandering to local prejudices about Britishness and sweeping aside careful consideration of ethnic and cultural historical identies. Have members of the British community been consulted about this trivialisation of their culture for entertainment purposes? I demand protests and long articles featuring complicated academic words such as "implicit dichotomisation".
Hear, hear!
Personally I am sick and tired of my Dutch culture being appropriated by so-called Dutch wives in Japan, which are inevitable poorly-thoughtout cliches of the original, pandering to local prejudices about Dutchness and sweeping aside careful consideration of ethnic and cultural historical identies. Have members of the Dutch community been consulted about this trivialisation of their culture for entertainment purposes? I demand protests and long articles featuring complicated academic words such as "implicit dichotomisation"...
inflames wrote:Russell wrote:yanpa wrote:Personally I am sick and tired of my British culture being appropriated by so-called British-themed pubs in Japan, which are inevitable poorly-thoughtout cliches of the original, pandering to local prejudices about Britishness and sweeping aside careful consideration of ethnic and cultural historical identies. Have members of the British community been consulted about this trivialisation of their culture for entertainment purposes? I demand protests and long articles featuring complicated academic words such as "implicit dichotomisation".
Hear, hear!
Personally I am sick and tired of my Dutch culture being appropriated by so-called Dutch wives in Japan, which are inevitable poorly-thoughtout cliches of the original, pandering to local prejudices about Dutchness and sweeping aside careful consideration of ethnic and cultural historical identies. Have members of the Dutch community been consulted about this trivialisation of their culture for entertainment purposes? I demand protests and long articles featuring complicated academic words such as "implicit dichotomisation"...
I heard Turks got the name Turkish bath changed...
Crispin Busk, the founder of our noodle empire
Samurai_Jerk wrote: That site's an SJW's wet dream.![]()
matsuki wrote:Crispin Busk, the founder of our noodle empire
There is an Indio Muerto Street here in Santa Barbara. Indio Muerto is Spanish for Dead Indian. Several years ago a group of college students decided that the name was racist and had to go. They had protests and everything.
The Native American tribe that is local to Santa Barbara is the Chumash. One of the Chumash elders was asked by a reporter at the local newspaper if he found the name of the street offensive. Thinking about his reply makes me smile to this day. "What I find offensive," he said, "is a group of white college students taking offense on my behalf."
wagyl wrote:I just came across this elsewhere on the web and it reminded me of this thread.There is an Indio Muerto Street here in Santa Barbara. Indio Muerto is Spanish for Dead Indian. Several years ago a group of college students decided that the name was racist and had to go. They had protests and everything.
The Native American tribe that is local to Santa Barbara is the Chumash. One of the Chumash elders was asked by a reporter at the local newspaper if he found the name of the street offensive. Thinking about his reply makes me smile to this day. "What I find offensive," he said, "is a group of white college students taking offense on my behalf."
matsuki wrote:LOL....but were they actually white?
High School student's costume called out cultural appropriation
One student really mixed things up at his school's spirit week.
While most classmates dressed up in traditional costumes representing different cultural backgrounds for Culture Day, Josh Welch dressed up as a thief – representing white people stealing other cultures.
Samurai_Jerk wrote:I'm offended this anti-white racism.
High School student's costume called out cultural appropriation
One student really mixed things up at his school's spirit week.
While most classmates dressed up in traditional costumes representing different cultural backgrounds for Culture Day, Josh Welch dressed up as a thief – representing white people stealing other cultures.
Screwed-down Hairdo wrote:Cultural appropriation is one of the most dumbfuck Merkin ideas I have ever come across.
Screwed-down Hairdo wrote:Cultural appropriation is one of the most dumbfuck Merkin ideas I have ever come across.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 9 guests