
He denied that overseas music was declining in popularity, pointing out that it had always been around 20-25% of the market but sales had obviously fallen as the market contracted. Morita confirmed that Japanese consumers download music to their mobile phones much more than they download to PCs which is notably different to trends elsewhere in the world. He claimed that Japanese labels had taken pains to ensure that consumers were "educated" to pay for music, which was important for the artists, and contrasted this with markets in the west where music. Many of the other discussions at MIDEM in fact took it for granted that music was increasingly seen as a "free" good and were focused on how to capture revenues elsewhere. A guy from Amazon Japan asked Morita whether Sony would consider offering DRM-free music to download to which he replied "Never". He understood that people wanted the freedom to play downloads on several platforms but said that there was no way to limit the number of copies someone could make without DRM. He complained that, although Japan has now introduced legislation which outlaws illegal downloading, the laws carry no penalties and Sony was lobbying for their introduction as well as pressing the police for greater enforcement. The response from most at the conference was that if Japanese labels thought they could keep consumers paying for music then all power to them. The feeling was, however, that the fight had already been lost and Morita was just hoping to delay the inevitable. As an aside, the Sony man mentioned that his daughter uses an iPod rather than a player from his own company.