gboothe wrote:The difference is they can all play a reasonable amount of defense. Matsui is only passible at that at best and with little to no arm.
This is completely true. He can't run. He can't really throw (though in comparison to Damon he has a canon). But for some reason his lack of defense never gets mentioned.
I don't think they'd unload Matsui - at least not for a few years. They'd dump Sheffield before that would happen. And I think next year Sheff will be the guy to go since they have to swallow Abreu's $15 mill. Even Steinbrenner has his limits.